Thursday, July 30, 2020

Privilege and Game Difficulty

Several years ago there appeared an article somewhere about communicating of advantage and privilege by reference to computer games. The point being that being a white male in a developed country means playing the game of life on the Easy Level. Being coloured, female or poor means increasingly hard work to "win" at life. It is possible but not difficult.

Which raises the thought that the flip-side might be an interesting way to code a game. The difficulty level is chosen by selecting the player character. Again rich white male is the easy level. Many games already allow you to chose to start with less resources, so you have to work hard to catch up before continuing. In online games you can buy your way in with real money.
Following the same line of thinking, playing as female should mean you need twice as many XP to level up, thus replicating the real world more closely. Being non-white can impact the way NPCs react, prices in stores, the approach of the guards etc. Further separation by using different levels of "non-white" based on the culture of the level - although that gets a little more complicated.

I am not sure if this is a good idea or not. On the one hand, it highlights the problems that many members of our society deal with. Making the issues relate-able to those cause the problem may help. It also allows people to generate characters that are more similar to themselves, or to experience how the other 1% live.
On the other hand, is it likely to institutionalise the view that rich, white and male are the only way to be and anyone else is somehow less.

Thursday, July 23, 2020

Platform Selection

Digital platforms are a trend in IT and larger enterprises are adopting them heavily. Any platform provides a set of related technical services which may be configured to create applications that support business operations. There are variety of types available, each with their own strengths and weaknesses, and it not always clear which is most suitable.

The current crop of available products overlap a great deal; and market forces are leading the major vendors to include  everything for everybody. The point of the following diagram is not to be absolutely correct with the capabilities of different types of platform. It is to show the similarity in feature sets.


If your needs are straightforward and your usage is not complex, then almost any common digital platform will probably fit your needs. But vendor history and product origins are still manifest in core of the platforms they produce. Selecting the right one means choosing a vendor whose focus best aligns with the core business of your organisation.

Governance and due diligence in the finance industry means that repeatable, verifiable process is more important than individual customers. Health necessarily relies on individual attention and expert judgement. The core systems in each case have different basic characteristics even if the surface functionality is similar.

It shouldn't need saying but understanding your business, and explicitly recording its purpose, simplifies the selection process enormously.